Which of these 5 rock albums do you think is the best and why?

Guns N Roses - Appettite For Destruction

Metallica - Metallica (Black Album)

Pearl Jam - Ten

Nirvana - Nevermind

Oasis - What's the Story (Morning Glory)

Which of these 5 rock albums do you think is the best and why?
Pearl Jam - Ten



first album I ever owned.

Pearl Jam is my favorite band.



it doesn't have any 'skip songs' - its one of those cds you can just put on and let it play through.



Nevermind and Appetite are a VERY close 2nd and 3rd.
Reply:Nevermind is seriously overrated.

Ten is actually much better than Never mind in my opinion.

im not really a fan of heavy metal, but i like grunge. Oasis however is going to get my vote. Whats the story(morning glory) is really great, its one of my favorites.
Reply:pearl jam. great song lyrics
Reply:Of those choices:



What's the Story (Morning Glory)



even though Nevermind is amazing, that particular Oasis record just has some really class songs...



....but if the Metallica choice had been "Master of Puppets", well, there would have been no contest! MOP is my fave album of all time.



GNR are well over-rated, and I could never get into Pearl Jam. Soundgarden. Yup. AIC. Oh, yeah. Nirvana. Too right. PJ. Nope!
Reply:Oasis - Whats the Story (Morning Glory)



They are all great albums but my favourite would have to be Oasis' album, just my personal preference, I have been an Oasis fan for more years than I care to remember and still love all their stuff! =]
Reply:well im a big metallica fan, but i prefer their first four albums, so im gonna say appettite for destruction
Reply:Not making it easy r u, they r all great in their own right however if i had to choose one only then Guns and roses.
Reply:Guns n' Roses - Appettite For Destruction



a fantastic album



although Pearl Jam - Ten was an amazing album
Reply:Nevermind by Nirvana - It has Smells Like Teen Spirit and Dave Grohl on Drums!!!



http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/search?ie=UTF...
Reply:Personally, Appetite for Destruction. I bought it at Woolworths in 1989 in Bridlington with my boyfriend. Now married and still gigging like kids.
Reply:Oasis - Whats the story (Morning Glory)
Reply:Appetite...solid throughout...set the stage for the other 4 you mention.
Reply:What's the story, simply because if I heard any of the others, I would have to turn them off; bad music makes me angry.
Reply:Pearl Jam- Ten

it's Pearl Jam. what else can i say? i like them.
Reply:appetite for destruction.



It always makes me feel 14 again.
Reply:Uh, the Black Album even though I liked their sound before the change.
Reply:I'm not even going to answer that.

That is too hard...
Reply:Nirvana-Nevermind

Though its not there best album

I'm a big fan of Nirvana
Reply:i would say nirvana mainly because they are an awesome band one of my favs out of the list.



all the bands are good though
Reply:All great albums. Had to think about Nevermind and AFD. But i know that today if i had to choose which album to listen to i would picke AFD. so i that would be my choice. I think the anger is true, the moments of compassion are true, you can really feel what these guys were going through circa LA in the mid 80's. Feels real to me.
Reply:Oasis - What's the story (Morning Glory)

Just because it's got some really good songs on it.
Reply:Nirvana - Nevermind.



Because it is, simple as that. :D
Reply:pearl jam because it's a beautiful piece of music. i like it a lot.
Reply:Guns N Roses and Nirvana because I love their sound
Reply:i think nevermind is the best...among those it is the best written and produced and really set off the popularity of the grunge sound as a whole...appetite for destruction is a pretty close second, but nevermind was deeper in terms of great songs and content
Reply:Guns N Roses- Appetite For Destruction.



I love Nevermind, but Appetite is a much better album. I have never been a Metallica fan, and I hate Pearl Jam.
Reply:Oasis.....Thats a great album. Takes me back.
Reply:Guns 'N Roses - Appetite For Destruction



Because the other ones only have a handfull of good songs on them while G'NR's album every song great! There isn't one bad song on the whole thing! The other four all have songs on them I skip when listening to it. I never skip a song on Appetite For Destruction. After that I'd put Metallica as the second choice, then Pearl Jam, then Nirvana, then Oasis. As I'm typing that I just noticed that is the exact order you put them. Hmmmm?! Is that the order you like them too?



P.S. I might switch the order of Pearl Jam and Nirvana depending on my mood on a different day.