Do you agree that Oasis are overrated and just living off the reputation of some great early songs?

Definitely Maybe was great.

Morning Glory not quite as good.

Be Here Now self indulgence.

After that I gave up.

Do you agree that Oasis are overrated and just living off the reputation of some great early songs?
Oasis are constantly in competition with themselves,trying to top their earlier stuff.songs like Lyla would be career highs for other bands but compared to Live Forever,it just isnt that great
Reply:Definitely maybe!!! But im well happy with it!!!
Reply:I like the Summer Fruits flavour the most, very refreshing!
Reply:Definately Maybe is still a blinding album, and ...Morning Glory was good but not great, and that's when I gave up. Everything else since has sounded like a third-rate Beatles tribute band. So yes, they are hugely overrated now and are definately living off past glories.
Reply:yes. noel is much better than liam. dey had a few good hits but they are fading away into uselessness
Reply:Never really rated them anyway. Always thought they were a rip off beatles clone. Became famous for animosity between them and Blur, who were much more original. If they weren't fronted by the Gallagher brothers, with their arrogance, they wouldn't have lasted this long.
Reply:I did'nt even realize they were still playing music...but then I don't listen to commercial radio anymore...

try Arcade Fire.. love them very Joy Division feel to their music
Reply:no, i`ve been a fan for 10+ years...i don`t think they are finished, i agree that their music now isn`t up to the same quality as their earlier stuff, but i`m not giving up on them just yet!!!